Elliptical Machine Vs Treadmill

Cardio workouts like running are a central feature of many fitness routines, but heading outside isn’t always an option. With unpredictable weather, tight schedules, or perhaps an injury lots of people lean on gym equipment to keep up with their training. The two most popular choices? The elliptical machine and the treadmill. In this article I discuss which one might fit your goals, break down what each machine really offers, and what sets them apart.

The Basics: Getting to Know the Elliptical and Treadmill

The treadmill is basically a moving belt that lets you walk, jog, or run in place. You control the speed and, on many models, the incline, giving you the flexibility to adjust the intensity of your workout. Treadmills are popular among runners and anyone training for races. They’re also a familiar choice for anyone who prefers straightforward cardio.

Elliptical machines use pedals and often moving handlebars, making your feet move in an oval or “elliptical” path. This setup keeps your feet on the pedals, with no pounding the ground, so the impact on your joints is much lower. Some ellipticals allow you to pedal backward, and the arm handles can help work your upper body too.

The movement is very different. Treadmills mimic outdoor running or walking, while ellipticals feel more like a smooth glide, kind of like skiing or stair climbing. Trying both for a session or two is a smart way to get a sense of what feels best for your body and fitness style.

Major Benefits of Each Machine

Treadmill Pros

• Custom Control: You can fine-tune your workout, shifting speed and incline for just the challenge you want. This is great for interval training, HIIT, or recreating race conditions indoors.
• Natural Movement: Running or walking on a treadmill feels a lot like hitting the pavement outside, so if you’re training for a 5K, half-marathon, or want to keep your natural stride, a treadmill fits the bill.
• Calorie Burn: High-intensity intervals or steady-state runs on the treadmill help burn calories fast, making it popular for those aiming for weight loss.
• Versatility: Treadmills allow you to walk, jog, power-walk, or sprint, depending on how you feel each day. That versatility makes it suitable for all fitness levels.
• 

Elliptical Pros

• Low Impact Cardio: Since your feet never leave the pedals, there’s less stress on your knees, hips, and back. This is a huge perk if you have joint pain or are recovering from an injury.
• Full Body Workout: Most ellipticals come with moving handles, so you can push and pull with your arms as you pedal, hitting your chest, back, and shoulders along with your legs.
• Variation: You can usually pedal backward for a change of pace, engaging different leg muscles groups such as your hamstrings and calves.
• Gentler on Recovery Days: The smooth motion makes ellipticals useful for active recovery or when you want to keep up the cardio without putting much strain on your body.

Drawbacks to Consider

Treadmill Cons

• Impact: Constant pounding, especially while running, can be tough on your joints. Over time, this may lead to discomfort or even injuries like shin splints or knee pain, especially without proper footwear or running form.
• Monotony: Running in one place can get a bit dull if you rely on treadmills too often. Some people find it hard to stay motivated.
• Risk of Falls: If you trip or lose your balance, the moving belt means you might take a tumble. It’s smart to always use the safety clip if your treadmill has one.
• Noise: Treadmills can be loud, which might be disruptive if you’re at home or sharing your workout space.

Elliptical Cons

• Less Specific for Runners: Elliptical training doesn’t perfectly replicate running. If you’re prepping hard for a race, the lack of impact and specific running stride might mean you aren’t training your body exactly the way you need to.
• Can Feel Awkward at First: Some people find the stride of ellipticals strange in the beginning. It usually gets better as you get used to the motion.
• Limited Upper Body Engagement (On Basic Models): If your elliptical doesn’t have arm handles, it’s mostly just a lower body workout.
• Less Intense for Some: People who are used to high-speed running might find the elliptical less challenging unless they boost the resistance significantly.

Picking What Fits: Who Should Lean Toward Each Machine?

Your physical health, fitness goals, and personal preferences all play into which machine makes the most sense for you. Giving both a try and listening to how your body responds can help you spot the right match. Here are some clear pointers.

You’ll Probably Like the Treadmill If…

• You enjoy walking, jogging, or running for cardio.
• You’re training for a running race and want specific pacing and incline controls.
• You’re interested in building leg strength, stamina, and endurance.
• Joint pain or past injuries aren’t an issue for you.
• You want a machine that mirrors outdoor workouts as closely as possible.

The Elliptical Is Worth Checking Out If…

• You’re prone to injuries or dealing with knee, hip, or back pain.
• You want a cardio workout that feels gentler but still gives your heart and respiratory rate a boost.
• You’re interested in including a bit of upper body work without needing extra time for weights.
• You’re looking to switch things up from your usual treadmill or running routine.
• You want a single session that targets both your arms and legs for a balanced approach.

Staying Safe on the Machines

For both machines, wearing proper athletic shoes gives you good grip and support. If you’re new to the elliptical, it’s usually a good idea to skip the arm handles at first so you can get used to the pedaling motion. Once you’re comfortable, adding arms to the mix can crank up your calorie burn and total muscle engagement.

On treadmills, the safety key or clip can be super handy. Attach it to your clothes so the belt stops if you stumble. Always warm up before you start hitting high speeds or steep inclines. This gets blood moving and helps you avoid pulled muscles or strains. Cool down and stretch at the end to keep your muscles happy and lower the odds of cramps or tightness.

No matter which machine you’re on, staying hydrated and listening to your body is really important. Stop right away if you feel dizzy or short of breath. And if you’re coming back from an injury or starting a new workout plan, checking with your doctor might make sense before you hop on.

Common Questions About Ellipticals and Treadmills

Can you burn as many calories on the elliptical as on the treadmill?
The short answer: yes, especially using high-intensity workouts. For many people, the treadmill edges out the elliptical a bit because running is a super energy-heavy exercise. That said, pushing hard on the elliptical, especially if you use the arm handles and add resistance, can burn plenty of calories, too. Calorie consumption comes down to intensity and effort.

---

Which is better if I have bad knees?
The elliptical usually feels much gentler on joints like your knees, hips, and ankles. Since your feet never leave the pedals, there’s little impact, so it could be a friendlier option if you’re managing pain or previous injuries.

---

Do either of these machines build muscle?
Both machines give you some lower body strength, but neither replaces a strong strength training plan. The treadmill builds endurance and can strengthen your glutes, quads, and calves, especially with inclines. The elliptical offers resistance for quads and hamstrings, and arm handles can moderately challenge your upper body. But if muscle size and power are top goals, cross training with weights is still your best tool.

---

Is it possible to get bored using just one of these?
Absolutely. Alternating between both machines, or mixing up incline, speed, or workout programs, keeps things fresher and more challenging. Many people throw in a little music, podcasts, or even TV to keep workouts lively, too.

---

Everyday Tips for Getting More from Your Workouts

• Try Intervals: Alternate between tougher and easier periods on both machines for a bigger calorie burn and more interesting workouts.
• Vary Your Routine: Mix treadmill and elliptical workouts each week. You’ll avoid overuse injuries and keep things from getting stale.
• Experiment with Settings: Play around with incline on treadmills, or resistance and stride direction on ellipticals to challenge different muscles and beat plateaus.
• Posture Matters: Stay upright, especially on the elliptical. Slouching can make workouts less effective and strain your back or shoulders.
• Set Goals: Tracking your sessions and noting your progress can make it easier to stay motivated, even when your routine gets repetitive.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both the elliptical machine and treadmill score high for cardio and calorie burn, and both offer strong benefits. Your decision comes down to what feels right for your body, what keeps you motivated, and what lines up with your goals. Some people pair them together throughout the week for more balance and less risk of burnout or injury. Whichever one you go with, consistency is what brings results. So, make your choice, lace up your shoes, and let it rip.